Call now
Project budgeting

Why Do Builders' Quotes Differ?

Compare specifications, exclusions, provisional sums and construction risks clearly.

Prepared 20 November 20265 min readBy Hepburn Architects
Quick answer

The essential position

Two quotations for the same drawings can cover different scopes. A useful comparison asks what each builder has actually included, omitted or assumed, rather than ranking totals alone.

Need advice on a specific property?Call David directly on 07720 813035 or book a free consultation.

Key points

  • Give every bidder the same drawings and specification.
  • Separate exclusions, provisional sums and client-supplied items.
  • Check who carries responsibility for design, temporary works and variations.

1. Start with one defined package

Provide consistent technical drawings, schedules and relevant structural information. If one contractor prices a fully finished room and another prices only the shell, the totals are not comparable.

Ask bidders to follow the same headings: groundworks, structure, roof, windows, first and second fix, finishes, services, external works and preliminaries. Any unknown work should be identified rather than hidden.

  • Same drawings and revision numbers
  • Schedule of works
  • Pricing return template

2. Spot common omissions

Check the kitchen, appliances, sanitaryware, floor finishes, decoration, skip and access costs, scaffolding, service alterations and making good to existing rooms. Look at drainage diversions, specialist glazing and structural temporary works.

A provisional sum is an allowance rather than a fixed price. Seek clarity on which material selections and ground conditions could change it.

  • Exclusions highlighted
  • Provisional sums explained
  • Contractor design assumptions

3. Compare risk, not just price

Review insurance, capacity, references, programme, subcontractor management and who will deal with defects. A quotation may be less complete because the bidder has not allowed enough time to interrogate the design.

Where tender information is incomplete, record the assumptions and decide whether to resolve design details before appointment. The cheapest tender is not necessarily the least risky choice.

  • Programme and staffing
  • Insurances and references
  • Variations process

4. Use a simple comparison table

Create one row per work package and record each builder's allowance, qualification and exclusions. Compare the adjusted scope without inventing a single 'true price' before tender clarifications are received.

Ask for corrected written quotations after clarifying the differences. Keep a contingency for genuine unknowns, not as a substitute for defining obvious work.

  • Priced packages
  • Clarifications
  • Agreed contract sum and contingency
Frequently asked questions

Questions homeowners commonly ask

Can planning drawings be used to obtain a building price?

They can support early budget discussions, but detailed tender quotations need coordinated technical information and clear scope.

What is a provisional sum?

An allowance for work not sufficiently defined when pricing. The final cost may differ from the allowance.

Official guidance and further reading

Get project-specific advice.

Every property has a different planning history, physical context and technical risk. Start with a focused review before committing to work.